I just finished BG1 and loved it! I rushed right out to buy BG2 and saw Icewind Dale on the shelf. Hmm, what to do?

Which game is better?

As I understand it, if I purchase BG2, I'll be able to import my BG1 character and work him up to about 20th level by the end of the game. With Icewind Dale, I'll start a new character at level 1 and build him through about level 14 by the end of the game. Is this correct?

Is Icewind Dale substantially bigger that BG1? How else would I get to level 14?

I really enjoyed to storyline aspect to BG1. Does Icewind Dale follow the same format?

Do both games use the same AD&D 2nd Edition rules?

Any input would be appreciated.

Ranger

you should try this post in the general discussion forum, or the player polls forum, you might getter more/better answers

Ranger,

I have both and both have their strong points. Different spells in both of them. Although, the majority of them are the same. If you enjoyed playing your BG character, then take him through BG II. When you are finished with that, take him through Throne of Bhaal. Then your character can get way up there.

Icewind dale was more of a linear game. Everything opened up in order. You have to finish this and then you can continue type game. Baldur's Gate II offers you more choices from a roleplaying perspective. You don't have to necessarily complete certain things in order. You can turn things down or accept them as you want. Other than the immediate story line, there are tons of side quests. You have more choices throughout the game.

Both are good. You can buy Heart of Winter to continue on your Icewind Dale series. So they're both good.

My vote goes for BG II though.

BGII in the house!!!!

Baldur's gate 2 is far better than I cewind Dale. There is no competition [img]smile.gif[/img]

i didnt enjoy icewindale because it was just fighting, fighting and fighting.

bg2 all the way, icewind dale sux compared to gate2

I would say you buy BG2. It is better in my opinion.

But Icewind Dale is pretty cool too. It may be more hack-and-slash,
but it's still a very good game.
I also think the snow in iwd looks really cool, does the atmosphere a lot of good.
I like some of the spell effects in iwd better than those in bg2
(Cone of Cold comes to mind...).

And iwd has really good music! I just love that Easthaven tune.

I have to agree with Keylow here. Sure it is a hack & slash like he pointed out but it sure has it's good bits. The first thing that I noticed in BG2 after drinking a normal potion was how the effects had changed. There are many things that I preffer more in one than the other which I will not really get into though. I would have to say that BG2 is (to my opinion) a more enjoyable game, but Icewind Dale (to my opinion again) is one not to be missed! It might be different in quite a few ways but sometimes a bit of change can be good [img]smile.gif[/img]

Both are good games and I spent hours playing them both. But if I had to choose I would recommend BG2, it's fun continuing the characters you build from BG1 abd finishing that story line. Plus BG2 has a ton of quests you can do and the character interaction and side quests are fun. Especialy doing the romances. Plus in BG2 you have Minsc. And as a member of ALSB you also get Aerie! I guess i should also mention Nalia and Jaheria.

You know what Ranger, I just might have the answer right here.
Get both games! I'm certain you'll have a good time with both.
Although this may not be an option when your a) short on funds and/or
b) short an time.

I think this is the best advice I can give you, because both games
are good. BG2 is al lot grander and has the beter story line, but
IWD has it's own charm.

[ 11-14-2001: Message edited by: Keylow ]</p>

i think that BG2 is alot better, but if u r short on HD space, get IWD. BG2 minmimum install = 500mg, Recomended= Approx. 1gig, Full= Approx. 2 gig. It is 4 cds, Iwd is only 2... but bg2 is more fun in the early bits (ive played bg2 up to chapter 3, iwd up to about the second task thingi), And i found BG2 alot better, there are more character types to choose from, You start at about lvl. 6 (depending on ur character- u start at the bg1 level cap) and you have a 3/4 top down view.
IWD u start with 0 xp, There r only the basic character types to chose from, You start at lvl.1 with 0xp, a goblin fight can kill u easily, and the view is terible.
And no, i dont think they both use 2nd edition adnd rules- In IWD, Raise dead cannot be used on elves, reserrection can, in bg2 both can be used on any race.

But if you do get both- play IWD first, otherwise ul find it very boring

Get Baldurs gate 2!!!!!!!!
Its much better than Icewind dale (which is a good game).
BG2 is bigger and you can get to a much higher level (20).
If you get Throne of Bhaal you can rise to the demi-god like level 40.

<blockquote>quote:</font><hr>Originally posted by Keylow:
But Icewind Dale is pretty cool too. It may be more hack-and-slash,
but it's still a very good game.
I also think the snow in iwd looks really cool, does the atmosphere a lot of good.
I like some of the spell effects in iwd better than those in bg2
(Cone of Cold comes to mind...).

And iwd has really good music! I just love that Easthaven tune.<hr></blockquote>

HELL YES!

There are a heck of a lot more useful spells than in BG2(who really needs 5 different spells to remove magical protections? Anyone?) and the environment is beyond compare.
And everything looks so much better than BG2.. Playing BG2 is less-linear but also less beautiful..
Get Heart of Winter and Trials of the Loremaster and you're pretty much set. Its both 2nd Ed DnD, but Heart of Winter has several 3rd Ed Abilities available..

If you want replayability though, get BG2. Icewind Dale is only good for the first 5 times :D :D

man... talking about beautiful

the icy snow covered dale lands are so much prettier than Amn [img]smile.gif[/img]
especially heart of winter... damn, just art