I just got the Carsomyr +5 from Firkraag, and I have Anomen in my party. He is level 12 as a cleric. Should I trade him for Keldorn or keep him?

get vicconia instead and give her crom faeyr

What are you playing and who else is in your party?

-- Nifft

I am a conjurer. My party is:
Minsc
Valygar
Jahiera
Yoshimo
Me
Anomen/Keldorn

Depends whether you want a cleric or not. I think Jaheira is enough, I played through with her as my only priest, we just bought restoration scrolls. But if you want a cleric then obviously go with Anomen. Because you do have three tanks in Minsc, Valygar and Jaheira, and Anomen can fight as well. But if you want the carsomyr, then go with Keldorn.

Keldorn with carsomyr and the gauntlets of dexterity are a great team.
A paladin equiped with that sword are a deadly force indeed.If you want to keep anomen for his cleric abilities then I would probably switch minsc and his humor out with keldorn.

Yeah, you'll have more offensive power with Keldorn. You don't need two clerics,(especially if one of them is Anomen)

It all depends if you want...

a- Either an extra Cleric that can also tank. You would get decent fighting capabilites and decent healing.

b- A really good fighter that would get you superb fighting capabilities and, well, no healing at all.

If I were you I would drop the both of them annoying dogooders (I just cant stand their dialog lines) and get Viconia. She is by far THE best cleric in the game and given certain conditions a pretty good tank. Besides, if you are a male you get to romance her which is really cool and the only worthy romance (Aerie and Jaheira suck real bad).